A Sermon on Genesis 1:20-31
by Rev. Chris Bohnhoff

I was able to buy my first house when I was thirty, an 80-year-old story-and-a-half fixer upper in South Minneapolis. In our seventeen years in that house, we touched every part of it. We replaced every appliance (some twice), upgraded the windows, shooed squirrels out of the attic, and addressed major structural issues. For all the money we sunk into that house, and as grateful as I was for a place of my own to live, sometimes I was convinced that buying that house was the stupidest thing I had ever done.

I remember being particularly overwhelmed by yardwork. To call it a yard is a kindness. After years as an unloved rental property before it came to us, it was overrun with weeds, and clumpy sedge grasses that refused to be mown, and Jerusalem artichokes spreading under the fence from next door. And against the foundation on all sides grew volunteer mulberry and hackberry trees that I waged war against for years.

That yard taught me the tenacity of plants, how they will not be subdued easily or quickly; how they have their own ideas about whose dominion is whose. It also taught me the challenges of inheriting a scarred, neglected piece of earth.

Will you pray with me? Holy One, we are your grateful people. We give thanks for our place among the plants and creatures on the land you separated from the waters. Your gifts never cease. You gave us the capacity to subdue the land and the creatures on it with cunning and with tools, and the intellect to understand the consequences of our actions. As we struggle with the tension between our ability and conscience, reveal to us the true nature of our place in the web of life, here in the quack grass and buckthorn, and guide us to right actions that bring balance, not extraction and exhaustion. Amen.

It’s an attractive word, isn’t it: dominion? It’s alluring to think that with the right leadership, the world could be brought under control, that chaos and harm may be subdued, and, better yet, that we are those right leaders. It’s so attractive that much of the western legal and political apparatus centers dominion: places and things under a person’s or a state’s right to own and control.

The book that I pulled our opening words from, How to Love a Forest, is a set of essays by a forester reflecting on caring for an 80-acre patch of woods in Vermont. But more than that, it documents one person living out a different definition of dominion.

As a young adult, the book’s author, Ethan Tapper, had life-altering experiences in the woods of New England. He and his friends backpacked for months, finding adventure and grounding in nature. Then, an accident took the sight from one of his eyes and he couldn’t be in the woods in the same way. Out of a lack of better options, he enrolled in university forestry classes, and his deep education on the history of the land he called home began.

Tapper learned about the socioecological history of the forest: how its indigenous inhabitants lived with and benefitted from the deep diversity and abundance of pre-contact land. How settler colonialists claimed dominion over those lands and cleared the forests to create pastureland for their sheep herds. Then, how foresters re-established the forests, but thought of them as crops to harvest.

He learned how foresters through most of the 20th century made forests efficient and harvestable like fruit orchards, and he learned the long-term impacts of that approach: the loss of wildlife diversity  and iconic tree species like the American chestnut from the eastern landscape, and the depletion of the forest floor’s nutrient base.

Tapper wrote, “As they managed forests like numbers on a ledger, I imagine that the scientific foresters believed they were doing something truly evolved: turning a wild thing into something refined and civilized. In truth, they were doing something truly primitive: transforming forests into savannas, managing a living system to comply with their most primal instincts.”[i]

When Tapper purchased his 80 acres, his small dominion, he reckoned with this colonized history of the land. He found abandoned machines and garbage left behind by logging crews. He found woods practically devoid of the oaks and maples that had been harvested a generation ago; and in their place large stands of sun-hogging, fast-growing trees that had choked out the oaks and maples, the trees that provide habitat for wildlife. And there was the overpopulation of sapling-eating deer to reckon with, the beneficiaries of the colonizers’ destruction of predator species.

And so, in the knowledge that every tree species has its role in the forest, and from a place of love for each of those species, Tapper set out to shape a dominion not to center human need, but to encourage the balance that characterizes a healthy forest ecosystem.

As Tapper discovered, it’s bittersweet work undoing our mark on the land. It involves pruning and cutting down invasive plants to make space for what was crowded out. It means some things must die, and even coming to understand death’s important role in a healthy forest. Death not as an abstract idea, but as the result of a chainsaw, guided by human hands.

As history has shown, humans do have dominion over all the earth, and the power to subdue all the creatures of the land, air, and sea. What will we do with that power? What lesson will we draw from Genesis: that God meant for us to dominate and subdue the earth for our own benefit, or that God meant for us to de-center our needs to maintain the balance that we were given?

The God-given gifts we’ve considered this month – the body, the mind, and the land – are together a complicated inheritance. They are all flawed, chaotic, and temporary; they all lie just outside our control. But despite their issues, our gifts are under constant attack. History’s greedy and fearful – call them empire, authoritarians, or settler colonialists – want us to disown our gifts and hand over their power to them. They peddle messages of comfort and control for the few and dangle the possibility that we can be one of them, insulated from life’s chaos, as long as we play by their us-versus-them rules of domination.

The question falls to each one of us: will we retain our claim on these gifts from God? Will we honor the beauty in chaos and brokenness and receive the wisdom they teach? Will we become ever more wise in discerning how to step into our own agency in ways that also leave space for the flourishing of all creation, not only ourselves and those like us?

What we need has already been given. The tools, the raw material for peace, for the creation of God’s commonwealth lay within us and all around us. May we use those tools, those battered, imperfect gifts with love and humility, and may we know that our small lives and acts of love are infinitely valuable in God’s sight. Thanks be to God. Amen.


[i] Ethan Tapper, How to Love a Forest, (Broadleaf Books: Minneapolis, 2024), p. 27-28.